Question:
Is "pi" rational or irrational?
Luis07
2010-04-30 20:38:07 UTC
How do we not know that it stops at some 19 trillion decimal places.

I know that from what I learned it is irrational, but sometimes I kind of have some doubts.
Eleven answers:
J
2010-04-30 20:45:04 UTC
you may prove that pi = lim (n/2) sin(360/n ) when n goes to infinity .-

So, n has no limit ( Infinity ) , then pi can´t be wrote like Pi = a/b , then is irrational NO DOUBT .-
?
2010-05-01 03:48:38 UTC
Because π is an irrational number, its decimal representation does not repeat, and therefore does not terminate. This sequence of non-repeating digits has fascinated mathematicians and laymen alike, and much effort over the last few centuries has been put into computing ever more of these digits and investigating π's properties.[23] Despite much analytical work, and supercomputer calculations that have determined over 1 trillion digits of the decimal representation of π, no simple base-10 pattern in the digits has ever been found.[24] Digits of the decimal representation of π are available on many web pages, and there is software for calculating the decimal representation of π to billions of digits on any personal computer.
Algebra House
2010-05-01 03:44:50 UTC
pi is irrational



a rational number can be written as a fraction

- any terminating or repeating decimal is rational



an irrational number cannot be written as a fraction

- any non-terminating, non-repeating decimal is irrational

- in other words, it goes on forever without repeating
Chris S
2010-05-01 03:41:19 UTC
we assume it is irrational because the billions of decimal places we have calculated have showed no sign of repeating or terminating, we can never be 100% sure though because we would have to calculate it to its last decimal place which would take an infinite amount of time if it were indeed irrational.
Steven
2010-05-01 03:43:28 UTC
it is irrational



there are many proofs to confirm this



the decimal representation does not stop (ever). Otherwise it would be rational.



advanced technology (esp. computers) have determined its value to many (19 trillion?) decimal places, but it is a number that (in decimal format) continues forever... without a continuous repeating sequence of digits.
Myles M
2010-05-01 03:41:20 UTC
It is irrational as it is never ending(as far as we know and know it to billions of places)
?
2010-05-01 03:41:35 UTC
you can use Archimedes's method(which is still in use today to determine some million digits of pi) some billion trillion times to see for yourself whether it stops or not (i highly doubt it)
Richard M
2010-05-01 03:44:08 UTC
Rational means it can be expressed as a ratio that is a fraction. 22/7 is sometimes used as that fraction but it isn't pi

So it isn't rational.
The Ex
2010-05-01 03:44:06 UTC
It is irrational, and there are several proofs on Wikipedia.
anonymous
2010-05-01 03:40:12 UTC
it is rational, but its just an extremely long number. An irrational number would be like the fraction 1/3. It would be 0.333333333333333333333333 and continue on forever.
James
2010-05-01 04:03:54 UTC
irrational


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...