Question:
Does zero divide only zero?
maths mania
2008-07-22 04:20:15 UTC
If it is true that zero divides only zero, then is it still possible to say that 0/0 is indeterminant? Please help.
Twenty answers:
JCS
2008-07-22 07:33:58 UTC
Sorry to say, but all the answers above are wrong.



In INTEGER division, it's true that 0 divides only 0. This is a consequence of the definition of a|b (a divides b), where a,b ∈ Z:



a|b ⇔ ∃k∈Z (b = k×a)



Now, if a = 0 then, necessarily, b = 0 too, so:



0|a ⇒ b = 0



Now, this is different from the statement "0/0 is an indetermination" because, in this context, 0/0 doesn't refer to integer division, but to Real Analysis instead, and means that, if you have two real functions f(x) and g(x), such that:



lim[x → a]f(x) = lim[x → a]g(x) = 0



then lim[x → a](f(x) / g(x)) cannot be determined directly, and depends on the local behaviour of the particular functions.
2016-04-02 07:48:06 UTC
Division by zero is an operation for which you cannot find an answer, so it is disallowed. You can understand why if you think about how division and multiplication are related. 12 divided by 6 is 2 because 6 times 2 is 12 12 divided by 0 is x would mean that 0 times x = 12 But no value would work for x because 0 times any number is 0. So division by zero doesn't work.
jai chandran R
2008-07-22 23:43:32 UTC
no, it is not possible to divide by zero



zero=nothing; how could you divide by nothing ? is it possible ?



for example:



zero divided by number(0/x)



let a=0;

multiply by 1 on both side

a*1=0*1;

hence

a*1=0;

now take that one to other side

a=0/1;

that is nothing but

a=0;

so, any number which divides zero is zero



but if we take another statement(number divided by zero) x/0?

let a=0;

multiply by zero on both side;

a*0=0*0;

we may thing we can cancel the zero on both side but (once the values on the both sides are zero, we cannot put equal inbetween two conditions )

so, a*0=0*0===>0

hence, we cant divide any number by zero, if it is the condition, how come we can divide zero by zero??
♥♫μάηηά♥♫
2008-07-27 06:11:53 UTC
No zero does not divide any number



even zero/zero(0/0) is an undefined number.



and if v divide any number by zero(0) then d solution will b infinite.



plz vote me the best answer.
triangl1988
2008-07-22 04:35:20 UTC
zero does not divide zero. in fact it does not divie anything. everything divides zero.



x^2 / x tends to 0 as x tends to 0, but x / x^2 tends to infinity as x tends to 0. yet these two expressions come out as 0/0.



and it is possible to construct examples which tend to any limit you like. which is why it is indeterminant
kicking4jc
2008-07-22 04:29:46 UTC
Any number can be divided into 0.



You just can not divide any number by 0, including 0.
2008-07-22 04:29:05 UTC
1. A number cannot be divided by zero, so it's not true that zero can only be divided by zero.



2. A number divided by itself equals 1, so 0/0 = 1 is false.



So, zero cannot be divided by zero.
Cogent
2008-07-23 05:42:36 UTC
Yes, zero divides only zero.

When 0 is divided by 0, remainder is 0 (whatever may be the quotient).But we cannot decide the quotient.0/0 is indeterminate.
Mrudul S
2008-07-22 04:44:29 UTC
Zero cannot divide any number including zero itself. Any number divided by same number the answer is 1. But this doesnot hold true in case of zero.
2008-07-22 04:28:22 UTC
Yes and no. 0 does not divide 0, still undefined.

0/0 is indeterminate and you may apply L'Hopital's Rule.
Golden Ratio
2008-07-24 12:41:35 UTC
If not in a purely math sense, I'd say 0/0 = 0.

That's because, when nothing is divided by nothing, it results in nothing.
OldPilot
2008-07-22 04:29:57 UTC
Zero does NOT divide anything. In every case, the answer is indeterminate. ALWAYS.



Example from Calculus:



(X-3)/(X^2 -9) = ?

Plug in x=3 and you get 0/0 or 1 But is that correct? Try it again with x = 2.99

(2.99 -3)/(8.94 -9) = 0.01/0.06 = 0.1666666



(x-4)/(x^2 - 16) = ?

Plug in x=4 and you get 0/0 or 1 But is that correct? Try it again with x = 3.99

0.01/(15.92 - 16) =

0.01/0.08 = 0.125



Different answers as we get close to x. Very important result.
2008-07-22 04:29:01 UTC
I think so because 0 is nothing.



It is an empty number



And also when you try dividing 0 by any nonzero digit in a scientific calculator, it reads out "Math error"
2008-07-22 04:47:01 UTC
0/0

= undefined
An ESL Learner
2008-07-22 04:33:32 UTC
0/0

= undefined
Avdhut M
2008-07-22 04:29:17 UTC
0/0=0
2008-07-23 08:05:39 UTC
yes it is right zero divied only zero say it 0\0.
Afsa Shys
2008-07-23 00:59:12 UTC
dont think so
siddharthagovinda
2008-07-22 04:28:19 UTC
No, it is undefined.
leandrocs_1310
2008-07-22 11:07:01 UTC
I don't know.


This content was originally posted on Y! Answers, a Q&A website that shut down in 2021.
Loading...